The Eleven-Minute Encore That Became an Anthem

Photo: penner / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0
Photo: penner / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

On the night of August 3, 1983, a former Minneapolis bus depot called First Avenue was holding a benefit concert.

The show raised money for the Minnesota Dance Theatre, whose founder had lent Prince rehearsal space and movement lessons.

Tickets cost twenty-five dollars, about five times the club’s usual price, and every one had sold within days.

Outside on the street, a mobile recording truck from New York’s Record Plant waited with its machines running.

Engineer David Rivkin, known as David Z., had been hired to tape the concert for reasons nobody fully explained.

His younger brother Bobby sat behind the drum kit onstage, keeping time for Prince and his reshaped band.

Beside Prince stood a nineteen-year-old guitarist named Wendy Melvoin, playing her first concert as a band member that night.

The band had already premiered several new songs, including the furious opener that would soon top the charts.

They had even covered a Joni Mitchell ballad, an early sign of the evening’s unpredictable ambitions.

Then the main set ended, the houselights stayed down, and the crowd demanded the band return.

Prince came back for an encore with a song that not one person in the room had ever heard.

It began quietly, with Melvoin’s guitar chords drifting over the hush of a thousand expectant strangers.

The performance stretched past eleven minutes, swelling from whispered confession to a guitar solo that seemed endless.

It was finished the first time anyone heard it.

There was just one problem.

Songs recorded once, live, almost by accident, were never supposed to become immortal.

Yet the tape rolling outside that night would outlive nearly everything else recorded that year.

A Country Song Nobody Expected

A year earlier, Prince had been a rising star with talent to spare and no defining anthem.

His fifth album, 1999, had carried him onto MTV and into the American top ten.

He was already planning a film, a semi-fictional story about a young Minneapolis musician called the Kid.

For that film he wanted a closing ballad big enough to hold an entire story inside it.

What he sketched first, surprisingly, was a country song, slow and wide open like a prairie hymn.

The melody arrived as a long instrumental, roughly ten minutes of chords searching for words.

Prince, who usually guarded his unfinished work fiercely, decided this one needed another writer’s heart.

He knew exactly whose voice he imagined floating over those chords.

He picked up the telephone and called Stevie Nicks.

The Cassette She Sent Back

Nicks had recently written her hit “Stand Back” after hearing Prince’s “Little Red Corvette” on the radio.

She had telephoned him in admiration, and Prince arrived at her studio within hours to play synthesizer.

He asked for no credit, and the two musicians became unlikely long-distance friends.

When Nicks later wondered aloud whether they might someday write something together, Prince answered with a cassette.

The tape held his ten-minute instrumental, together with a request that she supply the words.

Nicks listened to it again and again, by her own account, and felt the ground tilt beneath her.

The track felt less like a song, she said later, than like a movie waiting for weather.

She finally called him back and admitted defeat in five plain words: “It’s too much for me.”

She added that she was glad, because the song plainly belonged to him alone.

So the country ballad came home to Minneapolis, still wordless, still waiting for its band.

Photo: SandyMac / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain
Photo: SandyMac / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

Six Hours in a Rehearsal Room

Prince brought the instrumental to a Revolution rehearsal and asked the band to try something mellow.

Keyboardist Lisa Coleman later recalled that everything changed when Wendy Melvoin began voicing the chords on guitar.

Her voicings lifted the song out of its country setting and into somewhere larger and stranger.

The band leaned in harder, trading the gentle sway for a slow, gathering storm of sound.

They played the song for six hours straight, Coleman remembered, shaping it as they went.

By the end of that day, she said, the song stood mostly written and arranged.

Prince then wrote the words himself, building an apology and a blessing into a single address.

Within the film, its verses would play as letters to the people the Kid had hurt.

All that remained was to find out whether strangers could feel what the rehearsal room felt.

The Phone Call to Journey

One private worry still nagged at Prince after the arrangement settled into place.

The chord progression reminded him of “Faithfully,” the Journey ballad then riding the charts for Jonathan Cain.

Rather than risk a feud, Prince telephoned Cain and played him the unfinished song.

Cain listened and reassured him that the two songs shared only a handful of chords.

The blessing mattered, because Prince intended this ballad to sound like nothing except itself.

It is a rare window into a perfectionist quietly checking his masterpiece against the market.

Satisfied, he scheduled the new material for a public test in front of his hometown crowd.

One Night, Three Keepers

That test became the Minnesota Dance Theatre benefit at First Avenue on August 3, 1983.

The club, a converted Greyhound bus depot downtown, had been Prince’s proving ground for years.

Three songs from that single evening were later lifted, almost intact, onto the finished album.

Two were the dance numbers “I Would Die 4 U” and “Baby I’m a Star.”

The third was the encore, the long ballad Prince had carried in pieces for months.

David Z. captured it on the mobile unit, preserving every cheer and every ragged edge.

Drummer Bobby Z. would later call the evening one of the finest concerts the band ever played.

Back in the studio, Prince edited the eleven-minute performance down to eight minutes and forty-one seconds.

A guitar solo was trimmed, and an entire verse about money was cut away.

He judged that the money verse diluted the emotional impact the song needed to carry.

It was finished the first time anyone heard it.

The album version of “Purple Rain” is, at its core, that single unrepeatable live performance.

Photo: Christopher Bahn / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0
Photo: Christopher Bahn / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Strings Over a Live Tape

What the club tape lacked was the sweep that Prince heard in his head.

At Sunset Sound in Los Angeles, engineers layered overdubs onto the live recording during late summer.

Lisa Coleman devised the string arrangement that now rises beneath the final choruses like weather.

Violinist Novi Novog and cellists David Coleman and Suzie Katayama gave the track its orchestral glow.

The hybrid was unusual: a bar-band performance wearing the clothes of a film score.

Prince sang and played lead guitar, with Melvoin and Coleman conducting the strings they had shaped.

Bobby Z.’s electronic drums and Brown Mark’s bass kept the heartbeat defiantly human underneath.

Nobody involved could yet know how completely that hybrid would conquer the following summer.

The Album That Would Not Move

The album Purple Rain arrived in record stores on June 25, 1984, credited to Prince and the Revolution.

Its lead single, “When Doves Cry,” whose story this series has told elsewhere, ruled the charts for five weeks.

The film followed within weeks, turning the Kid’s story into the summer’s defining pop spectacle.

On August 4, the album climbed to number one on the Billboard 200 chart.

It stayed there for twenty-four consecutive weeks, into the January of the following year.

Twice it traded the summit with Bruce Springsteen’s Born in the U.S.A., a friendly heavyweight duel.

Certifications piled up until the album stood at thirteen times platinum in the United States.

Worldwide sales eventually passed twenty-five million copies, making it among history’s best-selling soundtracks.

At the center of it all sat eight minutes and forty-one seconds recorded in a club.

Number Two, Behind Wham!

“Purple Rain” itself was released as the album’s third single on September 26, 1984.

Radio could not play eight minutes easily, so the single carried an edit of four minutes and five seconds.

Even halved, the record climbed to number two on the Billboard Hot 100 that November.

It held that position for two weeks, blocked by Wham!’s exuberant “Wake Me Up Before You Go-Go.”

On the rival Cash Box chart, the song did reach number one and stayed for two weeks.

Belgium and the Netherlands also sent the record to the top of their national charts.

American buyers made it a gold single, a million-selling farewell letter from the summer of Prince.

The song that nobody could finish had become the song nobody could escape.

An Oscar and Two Grammys

At the Grammy Awards of February 1985, the album won Best Rock Performance by a Duo or Group with Vocal.

The album also won Best Album of Original Score Written for a Motion Picture or Television Special.

It was nominated for Album of the Year besides, losing nothing in stature by the company.

Prince collected a third Grammy that night as songwriter of Chaka Khan’s “I Feel for You.”

Weeks later, at the Academy Awards, Purple Rain won the Oscar for Best Original Song Score.

At twenty-six, he had collected music’s two most famous trophies within a single season.

Few soundtracks before or since have gathered both a Grammy haul and an Oscar.

All of it traced back to one benefit concert and one impossible encore.

The Song That Waits for Rain

After 1984, “Purple Rain” became the fixed summit of nearly every concert Prince ever gave.

He set it aside only during the years when he avoided his older hits altogether.

In 2004, he opened the Grammy Awards with it, trading verses with a young Beyoncé.

Three years later came the performance that fixed the song’s image for a new century.

At the Super Bowl halftime show in Miami, Prince closed his set with “Purple Rain” in falling rain.

Real rain poured over the stadium while purple lights turned the downpour into stagecraft from heaven.

That performance now regularly tops lists of the greatest halftime shows ever staged.

Rolling Stone placed the song eighteenth on its 2021 list of the five hundred greatest songs.

Pitchfork went further and named it the single best song of the entire nineteen-eighties.

You have probably stood in some doorway of your own life, watching weather you could not control.

That is why this song still finds you: it promises guidance through the storm, not escape from it.

Some songs are recorded; this one was witnessed.

Prince: The Purple One

A Name Borrowed from a Band

Prince Rogers Nelson was born on June 7, 1958, at Mount Sinai Hospital in Minneapolis.

His father, John Lewis Nelson, was a pianist and songwriter who had arrived from Louisiana in 1948.

Onstage, the elder Nelson performed under the name Prince Rogers, leading the Prince Rogers Trio.

The stage name reportedly joined the family dog’s name, Prince, to his own middle name, Rogers.

His mother, Mattie Della Shaw, was a jazz singer who became the Trio’s vocalist.

John had spotted Mattie at a Minneapolis show in 1956 and recruited her to sing with the band.

They married in August 1957 and named their son, born the next June, for that band.

All four of the boy’s grandparents had come from Louisiana, carrying its music north with them.

The child therefore grew up inside a household where songs were both trade and furniture.

His father later co-wrote several of the son’s records, including the piano piece “Father’s Song.”

That melody would echo through the film Purple Rain, played at a father’s piano.

The Piano His Father Left Behind

The marriage did not hold, and the parents separated while Prince was still a boy.

When his father moved out, the family piano stayed behind in the house.

Prince later recalled that he had not been allowed to play it while his father lived there.

Left alone with the instrument, the boy taught himself, key by key and chord by chord.

By seven, he had written his first song there, a small tune called “Funk Machine.”

He would master guitar, bass, keyboards, and drums with the same stubborn self-reliance.

For a time the teenager moved between relatives’ homes, carrying his talent like luggage.

The family of his friend André Cymone eventually gave him a basement room and stability.

In that basement, surrounded by borrowed instruments, the self-education became an obsession.

Grand Central

At Minneapolis Central High School, Prince formed a band called Grand Central with Cymone.

His drummer, Morris Day, would remain a comic foil and collaborator for decades afterward.

The band, later renamed Champagne, played dances, parties, and every stage that would hold them.

They covered Earth, Wind and Fire and learned how a Minneapolis crowd decides a song’s fate.

Local studio owner Chris Moon let the teenagers record demos at his south Minneapolis studio.

Moon heard enough in those demos to introduce the teenager to manager Owen Husney.

Husney packaged the recordings and carried them to the major labels on both coasts.

Several companies bid, but Warner Bros. Records offered the teenager something rarer than money.

They offered him the right to make his records his own way.

The Teenager Who Demanded the Controls

Prince signed with Warner Bros. in 1977, still in his teens, for a three-album deal.

The contract, reportedly worth about one hundred eighty thousand dollars, made headlines for its freedom.

He insisted on producing his debut album himself, a demand almost unheard of for a newcomer.

For You arrived in April 1978, two months before his twentieth birthday, entirely self-made.

Its credits listed him singing everything and playing reportedly twenty-seven different instruments.

Critics noticed the craft, even when the songs themselves still sounded like apprenticeship work.

What the album really announced was a method: one imagination, total control, no intermediaries.

He would defend that method against executives, bandmates, and trends for the rest of his life.

The industry had signed a singer and accidentally hired an entire record company.

Within a year, the investment began returning serious money and louder prophecies.

Five Albums in Four Years

His second album, Prince, appeared in 1979 and carried his first major hit single.

“I Wanna Be Your Lover” reached number eleven on the pop chart and topped the R&B chart.

Dirty Mind followed in 1980, recorded largely in a home studio and startlingly lean.

Critics who had filed him under disco began writing about him as an auteur instead.

Controversy arrived in 1981, its title track asking questions American radio happily repeated.

Then came 1999 in October 1982, a double album built like a warning and a party.

“Little Red Corvette” rolled into the pop top ten, powered by constant MTV rotation.

The same record nudged Stevie Nicks toward “Stand Back,” one good turn among several.

By 1983, Prince had the songs, the band, and the ambition for a film.

What he lacked, as the decade turned, was the one anthem that summarized him.

Photo: Al Beaulieu, distributed by Warner Bros. Records / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain
Photo: Al Beaulieu, distributed by Warner Bros. Records / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

The Revolution Assembles

The band behind him had been hardening on the road since the late seventies.

Drummer Bobby Z. Rivkin and keyboardist Matt Fink formed its long-serving engine room.

Keyboardist Lisa Coleman joined in 1980, bringing classical training and an arranger’s patience.

Bassist Brown Mark added the funk foundation that Prince’s studio experiments sometimes lacked live.

When guitarist Dez Dickerson left in 1983, Coleman suggested her childhood friend Wendy Melvoin.

Melvoin, nineteen, walked into the First Avenue benefit as the lineup’s unknown quantity.

Her guitar voicings had already changed the band’s biggest song before the public heard it.

Purple Rain became the first album officially credited to Prince and the Revolution together.

After the Rain

Fame on that scale could have frozen him, but Prince treated the summit as a starting line.

Around the World in a Day arrived in 1985, deliberately stranger than its famous predecessor.

Parade followed in 1986, carrying the number-one single “Kiss” and another film experiment.

Sign o’ the Times, a double album from 1987, is now widely counted among his masterpieces.

Lovesexy in 1988 and the Batman soundtrack in 1989 kept the annual rhythm unbroken.

He wrote hits for others almost casually, from the Bangles to Chaka Khan to Sheila E.

Paisley Park, his studio complex outside Minneapolis, opened in 1987 as a private creative city.

The Revolution had dissolved by then, but new bands formed around the same restless center.

Every year brought another album, because stopping seemed to frighten him more than failing.

Photo: Joel Bernstein / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain
Photo: Joel Bernstein / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

The Symbol Years

In June 1993, on his thirty-fifth birthday, Prince announced he was changing his name.

The new name was an unpronounceable symbol merging the traditional signs for male and female.

Newspapers, unable to print it, settled for calling him the Artist Formerly Known as Prince.

The gesture protested his Warner Bros. contract, which he felt controlled his pace and masters.

He appeared in public with the word “slave” written across his cheek in marker.

Albums arrived in a flood as he worked to fulfill and finish the old agreement.

During those years he largely avoided performing the hits, including this article’s subject.

When the contract finally expired at the end of 1999, the symbol’s purpose expired too.

In May 2000, he announced to the press that he would be Prince again.

Master of His Own Catalog

The new century found him converting defiance into honors with remarkable speed and grace.

In 2004 he entered the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in his first year of eligibility.

His guitar solo during that ceremony’s all-star finale became instant rock folklore.

The album Musicology and its tour returned him to arenas and American chart summits that year.

He treated honors as fuel, answering each tribute with another tour or album.

In 2014 he struck a new Warner Bros. agreement that returned ownership of his master recordings.

The deal also promised the deluxe reissue of Purple Rain that fans had demanded for decades.

Younger stars from Beyoncé to Bruno Mars cited him as a blueprint for total stagecraft.

Meanwhile the concerts kept selling out, powered by a catalog few living performers could match.

Photo: El Pantera / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0
Photo: El Pantera / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

What Remains

Prince died in 2016, and within weeks “Purple Rain” had climbed back to number four in America.

In Britain it reached number six, two places higher than its original nineteen-eighties peak.

In France it finally reached number one, thirty-two years after French buyers first charted it.

First Avenue painted his star on its exterior wall gold in tribute.

Estimates credit him with more than one hundred million records sold across the world.

Seven Grammys, an Oscar, and a Hall of Fame plaque only begin the accounting.

The deeper legacy sits in how completely he rewired expectations for a pop musician’s control.

He wrote, produced, arranged, sang, and played, then demanded the paperwork respect that fact.

Every self-contained artist since has worked, knowingly or not, inside his precedent.

He never chased the crown; he built one.

Photo: Lorie Shaull / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0
Photo: Lorie Shaull / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

Return once more to that converted bus depot on a Minneapolis night in 1983.

The benefit crowd has thinned in memory, but the encore still plays on tape.

A nineteen-year-old guitarist leans into chords that a band rehearsed for six straight hours.

A singer who demanded control of everything finally surrenders to a single live moment.

The truck outside captures the cheer that greets a chorus nobody had heard before that night.

It was finished the first time anyone heard it.

Everything since, the charts, the Oscar, the rain in Miami, unfolded from those eleven minutes.

The club still stands, its wall of stars keeping one painted gold among the silver.

And somewhere tonight, a singer is ending a show with it, trusting the old Minneapolis weather.

The encore is over; the rain has never stopped.

Leave a Comment

114visits all-time 6today