The Hit Its Singer Called a Throwaway

Photo: Art Siegel / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0
Photo: Art Siegel / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0

On March 28, 1967, a twenty-one-year-old singer from Belfast stood before a microphone in New York.

The room was A&R Studios, and the musicians around him were hired strangers assembled for the day.

He had arrived in the city only days earlier, carrying a guitar, a harmonica, and almost no money.

His band back home had broken up, his old record deal had expired, and this session was his last real chance.

A producer named Bert Berns had telephoned Belfast with an offer that sounded like rescue.

Berns had worked with the singer’s old band, and he wanted eight songs recorded quickly for his Bang label.

The singer, George Ivan Morrison, had signed the offered contract in haste, without a lawyer reading a word.

He needed the money, the momentum, and the escape, and he needed them all immediately.

That signature would follow him for the rest of his life.

On this first day, the band kept returning to one light, lilting song about a girl remembered from younger days.

The song had a calypso sway, a dancing bass line, and a chorus built for open car windows.

Take followed take, each one close, each one somehow missing the ease the song seemed to promise.

Twenty-one times the band played it through, and twenty-one times something felt unfinished.

Then, on the twenty-second take, the room loosened, the backing singers lifted, and the song finally smiled.

Nobody in that studio believed they had just made the most-played record of an entire decade.

The singer himself would later dismiss the song as a throwaway, one of hundreds he considered better.

The machinery of fame would spend the next year misunderstanding almost everything about him.

There was just one problem.

The tape kept the song; the contract kept the money.

A Telephone Call From New York

To understand that afternoon, you have to start with a band from Belfast called Them.

Them had burned brightly and briefly, selling records and chaos across Britain and America in equal measure.

By the middle of 1966 the group had splintered, worn down by management disputes and money trouble.

Morrison went home to Belfast, unemployed, unsure whether the music business wanted him at all.

Then Berns called, remembering the raw young singer he had produced during the Them days.

Berns was a Brill Building songwriter turned label owner, a man who wrote hits and made deals.

He offered Morrison a flight, a studio, and a fresh start as a solo artist in America.

What he did not offer, by Morrison’s later account, was time to have the paperwork examined.

It was, in short, the kind of offer a stranded singer does not refuse twice.

Eight Songs in Two Days

The plan was brisk even by 1967 standards: eight songs, recorded across two days, aimed at four singles.

The sessions began on March 28, 1967, at A&R Studios in New York City.

Berns produced, surrounding his new singer with some of the finest session players in the city.

Hugh McCracken and Al Gorgoni played guitars, Russ Savakus played bass, and Garry Sherman played organ.

Gary Chester, a drummer on countless New York hits, kept the time behind them all.

Behind Morrison stood the Sweet Inspirations, four gospel-schooled voices including Cissy Houston.

Morrison knew none of them, and by several accounts he barely spoke beyond the songs themselves.

The songs came from his own pen, written in Belfast bedrooms and on the road with Them.

The second day added more titles, all cut with the same brisk, unceremonious efficiency.

Twenty-Two Takes

The day’s most promising song was a wistful remembrance of young love in green, sunlit places.

Its verses looked backward at a girl the singer had known in his carefree years.

Morrison sang it again and again while the band searched for the right lightness of touch.

Only on the twenty-second take did performance and feeling finally arrive at the same moment.

That take, three minutes and five seconds long, is the recording the world still hears today.

A Song Built to Breathe

What the twenty-second take captured was deceptively simple: acoustic rhythm, a springy bass, and voices in sunlight.

McCracken’s acoustic guitar carried the rhythm while Gorgoni’s electric lines darted around the vocal.

The Sweet Inspirations answered Morrison in dancing syllables, turning memory into a call-and-response celebration.

Underneath everything, Savakus’s bass kept skipping like a stone across the surface of a pond.

The whole performance lasts barely three minutes, yet it feels like an entire lost season.

The Title That Changed on the Tape Box

The song Morrison brought into the studio was not, strictly speaking, called “Brown Eyed Girl” at all.

He had written it as “Brown-Skinned Girl,” a calypso-flavored number shaped by records he loved.

Somewhere during the session the title shifted, and Morrison later insisted the change was pure accident.

“That was just a mistake,” he explained, describing how the words on the tape box surprised him.

Other accounts suggest the softer title was always likely to travel further on American radio.

Whatever the reason, the new title stayed, and the original survives mainly as a footnote.

Green Fields Behind the Song

For all its Caribbean lilt, the song’s landscape was drawn from the streets of East Belfast.

Its opening verse name-checks the Hollow, a green valley barely two hundred metres from his childhood home.

The song works by memory rather than story, stacking bright images the way old photographs fall from a drawer.

Nothing dramatic happens inside it; two young people walk, laugh, and are separated by time itself.

That gentleness made the record unusual in a season of psychedelic noise and protest anthems.

Commentators have linked that pastoral glow to the Romantic poets Morrison read and admired.

One Line Too Many for Radio

Not every listener in 1967 found the song so innocent, however fondly it is remembered now.

One couplet, glancing at young lovers together in the green grass, was judged too suggestive by many stations.

Rather than lose the airplay, the label prepared an edited version for cautious programmers.

In that edit, a line borrowed from an earlier, innocent verse covered the offending words.

Both versions circulated, and the unedited master is the one that ultimately outlasted the censors.

Number Ten in America

Bang released the single in June 1967, with the short, sharp “Goodbye Baby” on its reverse.

Billboard greeted the record as an exciting debut and predicted a fast rise for its singer.

The prediction held: the record climbed steadily through the summer of the Summer of Love.

At the end of September it reached number ten on the Billboard Hot 100.

It stayed on the chart for sixteen weeks, longer than many number-one records of that year.

On the rival Cash Box chart it climbed two places higher, to number eight.

In Britain, curiously, the single made little impression, and Morrison remained a cult name at home.

For a singer whose band had folded months earlier, the top ten was vindication with a beat.

It was his first solo single, and it remains the calling card he never asked for.

An Album He Never Approved

Success created an immediate problem: the public wanted an album, and Berns intended to supply one.

In September 1967 he assembled the March session tapes into an album called Blowin’ Your Mind!

By the standard accounts, Morrison had no input into the album and no knowledge of its release.

Its psychedelic cover showed a singer who was already dreaming of entirely different music.

The album stalled at number 182 on the Billboard chart, a shrug beside its golden single.

The Contract That Ate the Royalties

Beneath the success sat the signature Morrison had scribbled in his haste to escape Belfast.

The contract, signed without legal advice, charged him with virtually all of his own recording costs.

Only after those costs were recovered would any royalty become payable at all.

Morrison has maintained ever since that he never received any royalties for writing or recording the song.

He vented his fury in a sarcastic throwaway of his own, a nonsense song about a big royalty cheque.

Decades later he recalled having to ask the label for a few hundred dollars simply to get by.

Bert Berns, the man who had signed him, died in 1967.

The dispute left Morrison legally tangled and effectively frozen out of recording for months.

The fight even shaped his songwriting ledger, as dozens of obligation songs reportedly poured out in one session.

The Other Seven Songs

The remaining songs from those two days followed as singles across the rest of 1967.

“Spanish Rose” and “Ro Ro Rosey” carried the Bang name into the charts’ lower neighborhoods without settling there.

Morrison later shrugged that he had written hundreds of songs he rated above the whole batch.

The sessions also produced the raw material Berns would mine for years in compilations.

One later collection even took its title from a blues in those tapes, T.B. Sheets.

Ten Million Plays

None of the bitterness slowed the song down; radio simply refused to let it grow old.

In 1999, BMI named it one of its hundred greatest songs of the twentieth century.

In January 2007 the recording entered the Grammy Hall of Fame.

Rolling Stone placed it at number 110 on its list of the five hundred greatest songs.

BMI certificates accumulated like rainfall: seven million American plays, then eight, then nine.

In 2011 the song passed ten million United States radio plays, a figure only nine other BMI songs had reached.

By 2015 it stood as the most downloaded and most played song of the entire 1960s.

Covers multiplied across the decades, from El Chicano and Jimmy Buffett to Steel Pulse and U2.

Springsteen sang it, Adele sang it, and ten thousand bar bands still tune up with it nightly.

Wedding bands, film soundtracks, and presidents’ playlists have all carried it into new rooms.

In 2006 the recording even surfaced on a Billboard ringtone chart, four decades after its release.

It is routinely described, even by reluctant admirers, as Morrison’s signature song.

You have heard it at a wedding, on a beach radio, through a supermarket ceiling, probably all three.

Somewhere behind it sits your own remembered summer, and the song politely lends you its sunshine.

The tape kept the song; the contract kept the money.

He called it a throwaway; the century kept it.

Van Morrison: Van the Man

Hyndford Street

George Ivan Morrison was born on August 31, 1945, at 125 Hyndford Street in Bloomfield, Belfast.

He was an only child in a working-class terrace in the east of the city.

Bloomfield was shipyard country, its terraces housing the men who built the great liners.

His father, also George, worked as an electrician in the Belfast shipyards.

His mother Violet had been a singer and tap dancer in her youth.

Music, in that house, was not a hobby but an inheritance waiting to happen.

His Father’s Records

In the early 1950s the elder George worked for a spell in Detroit, Michigan.

He came home with records, and kept coming home with them, until the collection dwarfed most others in Northern Ireland.

The boy grew up inside that library of shellac and vinyl, listening as other children might read.

Lead Belly sang there, and Mahalia Jackson, Muddy Waters, Ray Charles, and Charlie Parker besides.

His mother recalled him at two years old, tugging her apron strings, begging for another record.

The first record he ever bought for himself was by the bluesman Sonny Terry.

A father who collected songs had raised a son who would spend his life inside them.

Showbands and Saxophones

By his middle teens Morrison was playing guitar, harmonica, and saxophone with local showbands.

Showbands were Ireland’s musical apprenticeships: matching jackets, dance halls, and every hit of the day.

He toured with groups like the Monarchs, learning stagecraft in ballrooms far from home.

Skiffle had shown him that Lead Belly’s songs, already familiar at home, could ignite British teenagers.

He was, by his own later description, a working musician long before he was an artist.

Photo: Unknown author / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain
Photo: Unknown author / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

Them at the Maritime

In April 1964 he answered an advertisement for musicians at a new rhythm-and-blues club in Belfast.

The club was at the Maritime Hotel, and the band assembled there took the name Them.

The Maritime crowds came for American rhythm and blues delivered with local sweat and urgency.

Morrison fronted the group on vocals, saxophone, and harmonica, and quickly became its songwriter.

On Maritime nights his own new song, “Gloria,” could stretch to twenty minutes of gathering storm.

Decca signed the band, and London studios turned their Belfast fire into records.

Gloria, the B-Side That Would Not Die

“Gloria” reached the public in 1964, tucked onto the B-side of “Baby, Please Don’t Go.”

Radio and young America preferred the flip side, and the three-chord chant escaped its makers.

Garage bands everywhere adopted it as a rite of passage, three chords any beginner could conquer.

In 1975 Patti Smith opened her landmark debut album Horses with a fevered reinvention of it.

Meanwhile Them scored real hits, notably “Here Comes the Night,” written by their producer, Bert Berns.

That song reached number two in Britain in 1965 and introduced Morrison to Berns’s world.

In 1966 Them toured America for two months, then fell apart under arguments and empty pockets.

Frozen Out, Then Found

The Berns contract dispute left Morrison unable to record and nearly unable to perform in New York.

He married his girlfriend Janet and settled in Cambridge, Massachusetts, broke and far from home.

There he pared his music down, playing coffee houses as an acoustic duo with bassist Tom Kielbania.

Out of those hushed rooms came a cycle of songs unlike anything on the Bang records.

Warner Bros. came calling, expecting, by most accounts, more variations on his one famous hit.

Producer Lewis Merenstein heard the new songs in Boston and later said the title song made him cry.

Astral Weeks

Astral Weeks was recorded on three days in the autumn of 1968 at Century Sound Studios.

Around Morrison stood jazz musicians of the first rank: bassist Richard Davis and drummer Connie Kay among them.

Morrison sang from a separate booth, giving the band almost no instructions before the tapes rolled.

Asked what to play, Kay later recalled, Morrison simply told him to play what he felt.

Several tracks were first takes, the band following the singer the way weather follows a coastline.

Warner Bros. released the album in November 1968 and then barely promoted it at all.

It was not an immediate success with buyers or critics, and its maker was already moving on.

He was twenty-three years old, and he had made the album entirely on his own terms.

Yet the decades regraded it completely, until it stood among the most honored albums ever made.

Morrison himself later shrugged at the album’s canonization, as he shrugged at most verdicts.

Forty years on, Morrison performed the whole album live at the Hollywood Bowl.

Photo: Warner Bros. Records / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain
Photo: Warner Bros. Records / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

Moondance and the Long Road

His next album, Moondance, recorded back at A&R Studios, carried him to number twenty-nine in America.

Where the Bang single had been accident and compromise, Moondance was control, craft, and warmth.

Its title song, “Into the Mystic,” and “Crazy Love” became permanent fixtures of his concerts.

Songs like “And It Stoned Me” returned to the green fields first sketched in the Bang single.

With “Domino” in 1970 he reached number nine, his only other American top-ten single.

Albums then arrived almost annually, each following his curiosity rather than the market’s demands.

Tupelo Honey, Saint Dominic’s Preview, and Veedon Fleece deepened the catalog through the seventies.

He returned from a mid-seventies performing lull with Into the Music, songs of healing and home.

The eighties brought No Guru, No Method, No Teacher and a duet album with the Chieftains.

Avalon Sunset closed that decade, carrying a love song that Rod Stewart would carry to a Grammy.

The Last Waltz and the Working Years

Through the early seventies he toured America with an eleven-piece band, the Caledonia Soul Orchestra.

The live album It’s Too Late to Stop Now preserved that band at its joyful, swaggering peak.

On Thanksgiving 1976 he joined The Band’s farewell concert, the Last Waltz, in San Francisco.

His turn in a purple suit, kicking through “Caravan,” became one of the film’s immortal scenes.

By decade’s end he had largely stopped chasing singles and settled into the album as his canvas.

Photo: Egghead06 / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain
Photo: Egghead06 / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

The Later Harvest

The nineties found him duetting with heroes: John Lee Hooker, and the Chieftains from his own island.

Two such collaborations carried him to Grammy Awards at the 1998 ceremony.

Back on Top in 1999 gave him another radio staple in “Precious Time” and strong sales on both shores.

He recorded country standards on Pay the Devil and skiffle on Moving On Skiffle, still following his father’s shelves.

Critics noticed that the supposedly difficult singer had outlasted nearly every act that once overshadowed him.

He has released more than forty studio albums, a catalogue few living songwriters can match.

Photo: Chief Bulldeer / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0
Photo: Chief Bulldeer / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

The Singer and the Honors

His father, George, the great collector, died in 1988.

In 1991 he released Hymns to the Silence, a double album steeped in the Belfast of his childhood.

In 1993 he entered the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, and reportedly skipped his own induction ceremony.

Two years later he was photographed in Belfast with President Clinton, a souvenir of the peace-process years.

Photo: Bob McNeely / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain
Photo: Bob McNeely / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

His album title song “Days Like This” became an unofficial anthem of Northern Ireland’s peace process.

The honors kept their own rhythm: an OBE in 1996 and a knighthood in 2015.

In 2008 his all-original Keep It Simple reached the top ten on both sides of the Atlantic.

His daughter Shana, a singer-songwriter herself, has shared stages and songs with him for years.

Photo: Art Siegel / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0
Photo: Art Siegel / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0

He remains famously indifferent to applause, granting few interviews and fewer encores of sentimentality.

He turned eighty in 2025 with new music still arriving, including the album Remembering Now.

Belfast made the singer; the singer remade Belfast.

Go back, finally, to that New York room in March 1967, and to the twenty-second take.

A broke young exile sang three minutes of remembered sunshine into a microphone he did not own.

The musicians packed up, the label took the tapes, and the accountants took nearly everything else.

The tape kept the song; the contract kept the money.

Belfast eventually named a trail for its singers, and his childhood streets now draw pilgrims yearly.

Some hits belong to their decade; this one simply rents space in every decade since.

Photo: Jarvin / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0
Photo: Jarvin / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

Yet every summer since, somewhere, a radio has started those three chords and made strangers sing along.

The throwaway became the signature, and the signature outlived the grievance entirely.

Leave a Comment

120visits all-time 12today