…And Justice for All (1979) — Al Pacino

by

Al Pacino · 1979 · Signature Roles

…And Justice for All (1979) — Al Pacino

Arthur Kirkland is a Baltimore defense lawyer who believes in the law and watches it betray him daily: guilty clients freed on technicalities, innocent ones destroyed by procedure, judges who care more about reputation than truth.

Arthur Kirkland is a Baltimore defense lawyer who believes in the law and watches it betray him daily: guilty clients freed on technicalities, innocent ones destroyed by procedure, judges who care more about reputation than truth. Al Pacino plays him as a man whose idealism is curdling into rage.

The main gate of the Royal Courts of Justice in London.
Photo: David Castor, Wikimedia Commons, CC0 1.0 · Source

The film builds to a courtroom scene in which Kirkland, forced to defend a judge he knows is guilty, finally breaks — and Pacino plays the break not as triumph but as collapse. The shouting that became a catchphrase is, in context, the sound of a man losing faith in the only thing he trusted.

An empty historic courtroom interior with a raised judge's bench, witness stand, jury box and gallery seating.
Photo: Library of Congress, Wikimedia Commons, public domain · Source

It closed Pacino’s extraordinary 1970s run with another Oscar nomination, and it asked a question his whole decade of work had been asking: what happens to a decent man in a system designed to wear decency down?

Leave a Comment