Nature Boy: The Barefoot Mystic's Song That Made Nat King Cole a Star

https://thumb.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/8/83/Nat_King_Cole_%28Gottlieb_01511%29.jpg/500px-Nat_King_Cole_%28Gottlieb_01511%29.jpg?utm_source=commons.wikimedia.org&utm_campaign=imageinfo&utm_content=thumbnail

The Song That Arrived on a Tattered Piece of Sheet Music

There was a boy. A very strange, enchanted boy.

When Nat King Cole first sang those words, in the summer of 1947, nobody in the room knew quite what to make of them — least of all the man singing. The lyric was odd, mystical, faintly biblical. The melody wandered in a minor key like someone lost in a beautiful wood. And the man who had written it, the man who had slipped the tattered sheet music to Cole's manager backstage at the Lincoln Theater in Los Angeles, was himself the strangest part of the story: a barefoot wanderer in a white robe and sandals, with long hair and a beard, who spelled his name in lowercase letters because he believed that only the words "God" and "Infinity" deserved capitals.

His name was eden ahbez. He had been born George Alexander Aberle in Brooklyn in 1908, one of thirteen children, raised partly in an orphanage and sent west on an orphan train. By the 1940s he had remade himself completely: a follower of the *Naturmensch* and *Lebensreform* philosophies — German back-to-nature movements — living in a cave near Palm Springs, then under the Hollywood sign, eating raw food, communing with the desert, writing songs. He was, by any conventional measure, a vagrant. He was also about to write one of the biggest hits of the decade.

The story of how "Nature Boy" reached Nat King Cole has been told a dozen ways, and the details shift with the telling — ahbez approached the manager, or the valet; it was the Lincoln Theater, or the Million Dollar Theater — but the bones are consistent. In 1947, at the urging of friends including songwriter Johnny Mercer, ahbez pressed his grubby manuscript into the hands of someone in Cole's orbit. Cole looked at it, played through it, and was stopped cold. Here was something unlike anything on the hit parade: a haunting, minor-key ballad about a "strange enchanted boy" who learns that "the greatest thing you'll ever learn is just to love and be loved in return."

Cole began performing it live. The audiences leaned in. But he couldn't record it — not yet — because nobody could find the songwriter to sign the paperwork. Ahbez had vanished back into his wandering life. The search became part of the legend: they tracked him down living beneath the Hollywood sign, and when "Nature Boy" exploded, the press descended — *Life*, *Time*, *Newsweek* all ran the story of the robed mystic behind the number-one song in America, photographed like a desert prophet.

https://thumb.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/c5/Nat_King_Cole_1947.jpg/500px-Nat_King_Cole_1947.jpg?utm_source=commons.wikimedia.org&utm_campaign=imageinfo&utm_content=thumbnail

The recording itself happened almost by accident. On August 22, 1947, Cole was in the Capitol studio with a full orchestra conducted by Frank De Vol, the label's in-house arranger. With a few minutes of session time to spare, Cole suggested they try the ahbez number. What came out was extraordinary: Cole's velvet baritone floating over De Vol's lush, slightly melancholy strings, the lyric unfolding like a parable. It didn't sound like 1947. It didn't sound like anything.

Then came the musicians' union ban. In 1948, the American Federation of Musicians — the "Petrillo ban" — prohibited new recording, and Capitol, desperate for product, raided its vaults. "Nature Boy" was released on March 29, 1948, as the B-side of "Lost April" (catalog number 15054). Radio DJs flipped the record. The first to play it, Jerry Marshall at New York's WNEW, reportedly knew within seconds that he had something historic. The record debuted on the Billboard pop chart on April 16, 1948, stayed fifteen weeks, and spent eight of them at number one. It sold over a million copies.

For Cole, the song was a hinge. Until "Nature Boy," he was the celebrated leader of the King Cole Trio, a jazz pianist who sang. After it, he was Nat King Cole, the ballad singer — the voice that would define romantic pop for the next two decades. The song introduced him to the white mainstream market in a way the trio records never quite had, and it established the template: Cole plus a great orchestra plus an unusual, literate song, delivered with total sincerity.

Listen to the record today and notice how little it has dated. The arrangement is of its time — those sweeping strings — but the performance is timeless. Cole sings the lyric straight, without irony, without winking at the mysticism. "They say he wandered very far, very far, over land and sea." He believes it. That belief is the whole trick of Nat King Cole: he never stood outside a song commenting on it. He stepped inside and lived there for three minutes.

st51iTNnkeA

The song's afterlife has been remarkable. It became a jazz standard, recorded by everyone from Miles Davis to David Bowie to Lady Gaga and Tony Bennett. In 1999 it received the Grammy Hall of Fame Award. And eden ahbez? He never had another hit. He recorded a single album, *Eden's Island* (1960), a strange exotica record that flopped, and drifted back into obscurity, dying in 1995 after being hit by a car in Los Angeles. The quintessential one-hit wonder — one solitary, perfect, number-one hit that has retained its luster for nearly eighty years.

There was a boy. A very strange, enchanted boy. And for eight weeks in the spring of 1948, the whole country was enchanted with him — through the voice of Nat King Cole, who had the wisdom to recognize a miracle when a barefoot mystic handed it to him backstage.

The B-Side That Ate the A-Side

Here's a detail that tells you everything about how hits happened in 1948: "Nature Boy" was the B-side. Capitol released it on March 29, 1948, as Capitol 15054, with "Lost April" — a conventional, pleasant ballad — as the A-side, the song the label was actually pushing. The plan was routine: a new Nat King Cole single, A-side gets the promotion, B-side fills out the disc. And then the disc jockeys got the record, flipped it over, heard thirty seconds of "Nature Boy," and the plan disintegrated.

Jerry Marshall at WNEW in New York is usually credited as the first to play it, and the story — possibly apocryphal, but too good to discard — is that he listened to the A-side, found it unremarkable, flipped the disc more out of duty than curiosity, and then sat bolt upright as Cole's voice emerged from that strange, minor-key opening. Within days, other DJs were doing the same. Within weeks, "Lost April" was forgotten and its flip side was the biggest record in America. The B-side had eaten the A-side alive.

Capitol's desperation is part of the story. The 1948 Petrillo ban — the second musicians' union recording ban, called in response to the Taft-Hartley Act — meant no new recording sessions. Labels were raiding their vaults, releasing anything they had in the can. "Nature Boy" had been sitting there since the August 1947 session, an oddity nobody quite knew what to do with. The ban forced Capitol's hand: they needed product, and this strange, beautiful thing was product. Sometimes the music business works by accident, and the accidents are the best part.

https://thumb.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/1/17/Capitol_Records_78rpm_record_label_for_USA_release_of_Andy_Russell%27s_%22B%C3%A9same_Mucho%22._Original_issue._1944.jpg/500px-Capitol_Records_78rpm_record_label_for_USA_release_of_Andy_Russell%27s_%22B%C3%A9same_Mucho%22._Original_issue._1944.jpg?utm_source=commons.wikimedia.org&utm_campaign=imageinfo&utm_content=thumbnail

The ahbez Phenomenon

When "Nature Boy" hit number one, the press needed a story, and eden ahbez was the story of the year. Here was a man who looked like central casting's idea of a prophet — long hair, beard, white robe, sandals — who lived in a cave, ate raw vegetables, spelled his name without capitals, and had written the biggest song in America. *Life* photographed him. *Time* profiled him. *Newsweek* tried to explain him. He gave interviews in his gentle, wandering way, talking about Nature and God and Infinity, and the country was fascinated.

The frenzy had a dark edge, though. Almost immediately, claims surfaced that ahbez hadn't really written the song — that he'd stolen it, consciously or not, from other sources. The most persistent came from the Yiddish theater world: composer Herman Yablokoff claimed the melody was lifted from his song "Shvayg, mayn harts" ("Be Still, My Heart"). Musicologists have debated the claim ever since; there are melodic similarities, but also significant differences, and the question of unconscious borrowing versus deliberate theft was never resolved. Ahbez himself seemed untroubled by the controversy — or perhaps just unreachable by it. He had already moved on, spiritually if not physically.

What happened to ahbez after the hit is the saddest and strangest part. He got his money — Cole had insisted on a fair deal, reportedly giving ahbez fifty percent of the royalties — but money meant little to a man who'd chosen the cave. He recorded one album, *Eden's Island* (1960), a dreamy exotica record that sold almost nothing. He drifted through the fringes of Los Angeles counterculture, a ghost of the Summer of Love twenty years early. He died in 1995, hit by a car, largely forgotten — except for the song. Always except for the song.

Eight Weeks at the Top

Let's put the chart run in perspective, because "eight weeks at number one" doesn't quite capture it. In the spring of 1948, "Nature Boy" wasn't just a hit; it was a cultural event. It debuted on the Billboard chart on April 16 and stayed fifteen weeks, eight of them at the summit. It sold over a million copies in an era when a million was a mountain. It introduced Nat King Cole — previously a beloved but somewhat specialized taste, the jazz pianist who sang — to the vast white mainstream audience that would sustain him for the next seventeen years.

smldWXPePcM

And it did something else: it proved that the American public had an appetite for the strange, the mystical, the *different* — if it was delivered with enough beauty and conviction. "Nature Boy" is a weird record. There's no getting around it: the lyric is a parable, the melody is modal and wandering, the whole thing feels beamed in from another planet. In a year of conventional pop, it was the oddest thing on the radio. And it was the biggest thing on the radio. The lesson — one the music business keeps learning and forgetting — is that audiences are smarter and more adventurous than the industry thinks. Give them something real, and they'll find it.

The Standard

"Nature Boy" became a jazz standard almost immediately, and the list of artists who've recorded it reads like a hall of fame ballot: Miles Davis (whose 1950s version is a trumpet masterclass), Frank Sinatra, Ella Fitzgerald, David Bowie (who recorded it for the *Moulin Rouge!* soundtrack, introducing it to a new generation), Lady Gaga and Tony Bennett, George Benson, Celine Dion. Each version finds something different in the song — the Davis version is cool and detached, the Bowie version is theatrical, the Gaga-Bennett version is tender — but all of them are, knowingly or not, responding to Cole's original. He set the terms. Everyone else is commentary.

In 1999, the recording received the Grammy Hall of Fame Award — formal recognition of what everyone already knew. And the song's central line, "the greatest thing you'll ever learn is just to love and be loved in return," has passed into the language, quoted at weddings and in eulogies, printed on greeting cards, tattooed on skin. Eden ahbez, the barefoot mystic, wrote one of the most quoted sentences in American song. Not bad for a man who lived under the Hollywood sign.

There was a boy. A very strange, enchanted boy. He wandered very far, very far — from a Brooklyn orphanage to a Palm Springs cave to the top of the charts — and then he wandered away again, leaving behind three minutes of perfection and a mystery nobody has ever quite solved. But Nat King Cole solved the important part: he heard the song inside the tattered manuscript, and he sang it like it was the truest thing he knew. Because it was.