The Hit Its Writer Was Still Finishing in the Studio Washroom

Photo: Tullio Piacentini, Federico Zanni / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain
Photo: Tullio Piacentini, Federico Zanni / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

Forty musicians sat ready in Studio One at the Pye studios near Marble Arch.

It was Friday, October 16, 1964, and the session was about to begin.

Trumpets, trombones, violins and woodwinds waited in neat rows behind their music stands.

The Pye studios stood a short stroll from Marble Arch in central London.

Engineer Ray Prickett watched his levels from the control room that afternoon.

At the centre microphone stood a singer whose British career had quietly stalled.

Petula Clark was weeks short of thirty-two, a former child star living in Paris.

Her recent English singles had come and gone without troubling the charts at all.

Yet that whole orchestra had been booked to record a song nobody had finished.

Its composer, Tony Hatch, had carried the tune home from New York weeks earlier.

He had played it for her in Paris with barely two lines written.

She had heard it while making tea and chosen it on the spot.

Now, minutes before the session, the lyric still needed its final polish.

There was just one problem.

Hatch was in the studio washroom, still writing while the orchestra waited.

By Clark’s own later telling, forty musicians sat idle for his final lines.

When he finally emerged, the pages held a song about escaping loneliness downtown.

Nobody in that room suspected the next three months would rewrite her life.

Her brightest lights always burned in another city.

A Producer Hunting for Songs

Tony Hatch had worked beside Clark since assisting on her 1961 hit “Sailor.”

In 1963 her regular producer handed him the job of producing her records.

His first five English-language singles for her came and went without charting anywhere.

Hatch was twenty-five, ambitious, and running short of chances to prove himself.

Five singles into the partnership, the arrangement looked like a dead end.

By the autumn of 1964, her once-bright British career was foundering in public.

Hatch flew to New York that season on a three-day hunt for material.

He visited publisher after publisher, gathering songs for the artists he produced.

None of the songs he collected that week would matter half as much.

He had flown in for just three days of appointments and errands.

The melody that changed everything arrived while he was simply crossing a street.

The Corner of Forty-Eighth Street

Hatch was standing at a traffic light on the corner of Forty-Eighth Street.

He looked toward Times Square just as the evening neon signs flickered on.

He later recalled, “I wandered down to Broadway and to Times Square.”

A hotel room near Central Park had given him a base for exploring.

Naively, he assumed that glittering district was what New Yorkers called downtown.

In truth, downtown lay much farther south, down toward Battery Park.

The atmosphere delighted him anyway, all noise and promise and electric colour.

Somewhere inside that delight, a tune arrived almost fully formed in his head.

He said later that the song came to him very, very quickly.

By the time he flew home, the melody travelled with him like luggage.

A melody gathered on one Manhattan walk would soon circle the planet.

A Song Meant for Somebody Else

Back in London, Hatch imagined the tune as a doo-wop rhythm-and-blues number.

He thought it might eventually suit the Drifters, masters of that polished style.

His biggest success yet, “Sugar and Spice,” had borrowed the Drifters’ sound.

The Drifters’ records embodied the polished, urbane rhythm-and-blues he admired most.

He had already steered a Drifters cover into Julie Grant’s hands instead.

One later story claims singer Julie Grant was offered the song and declined.

Hatch’s own account disagrees, and he denies formally offering it to the Drifters.

He admitted the idea of a white woman singing it never crossed his mind.

So the most valuable melody of his career sat waiting for an owner.

Its future singer, meanwhile, was living in Paris and singing mostly in French.

Tea in a Paris Kitchen

Within days of the New York trip, Hatch flew to Paris with publisher songs.

Clark listened politely to three or four of them and liked none enough.

She asked instead whether he was working on anything new of his own.

Reluctantly, he played the unfinished New York tune on her piano that afternoon.

Beyond the title word, he had written only one or two lyric lines.

He slipped the single word “Downtown” into the melody wherever it belonged.

Clark had stepped into her kitchen to make a pot of tea.

From the kitchen she called out, “That’s the one I want to record.”

She told him to finish it properly, with a great arrangement behind it.

The publishers’ songs he carried were professional, polished and entirely forgettable.

Her Paris flat had by then become headquarters of her French career.

She wanted a song they could be proud of, hit or no hit.

Hatch went home to London with two weeks to complete the job.

An Orchestra Built Like a Rock Band

The session brought forty players together in Studio One on October 16.

Hatch insisted everyone perform together, the way a band plays on stage.

Eight violinists, two violas and two cellos formed the string section that day.

Four trumpets, four trombones and five woodwind players supplied the brass fire.

Pianist, bass player and percussionists anchored the rhythm underneath the singer’s voice.

The guitarists included Vic Flick, Big Jim Sullivan and a young Jimmy Page.

The Breakaways, a British girl group, added the bright backing vocal harmonies.

Hatch’s assistant Bob Leaper conducted while engineer Ray Prickett captured the sound.

His trick was making a giant orchestra behave like a rock band.

The arrangement had to thrill young buyers without alienating Clark’s older audience.

Clark later recalled three takes, with the second take becoming the record.

Every player read Hatch’s dense arrangement from charts prepared for that day.

The strings sweep upward near the end like a city lighting up.

Photo: Henk Lindeboom, Anefo / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0 NL
Photo: Henk Lindeboom, Anefo / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0 NL

The Record Nobody Knew How to Sell

Hatch played the finished recording for the executives at Pye with high hopes.

By his account, nobody there knew quite what to make of it.

No release date was set, and the tape seemed headed for a shelf.

Then Pye’s general manager mentioned a visiting American who was hunting British material.

Joe Smith, head of artists and repertoire at Warner Bros., was in London.

When Smith heard Clark’s record, he loved it instantly and completely.

Surprised, Hatch asked whether Smith considered it a very English record indeed.

Smith answered that its outsider’s view of America made it simply perfect.

Warner Bros. scheduled the single for urgent release across the United States.

Only after the American deal did Britain settle its own release date.

Number Two Behind the Beatles

Britain released the single on October 23, just one week after recording.

It entered the British chart in mid-November after her two-year chart absence.

Through December it climbed until only one record stood above it anywhere.

That record was the Beatles singing “I Feel Fine” at full imperial strength.

“Downtown” held second place for three weeks behind the biggest band alive.

A silver disc from Disc magazine marked 250,000 copies sold in Britain alone.

The song also reached number one in Australia, New Zealand, Canada and Ireland.

For a singer written off at home, the comeback was already remarkable.

Her two-year absence from the British chart ended inside a single month.

Christmas Rush to the Top in America

Warner Bros. released the single in the United States during November 1964.

Regional breakouts in Detroit, Miami and Washington told the label something special.

The record debuted at number eighty-seven on the chart dated December 19.

Christmas week was supposed to be the worst season for breaking hits.

Instead the song leapt to forty-one in only its second charting week.

It climbed through twelve and five and four as the new year opened.

On the chart dated January 23, 1965, it stood at number one.

It stayed there a second week before the Righteous Brothers replaced it.

It was the very first number one record of the year 1965.

Clark became the first British female artist to top the American chart in the rock era.

Only Vera Lynn, back in 1952, had managed the feat before her.

She also became the first British woman to earn an American gold single.

American sales passed a million copies while the record was still young.

When the news broke, Clark was playing small halls in Quebec, Canada.

She had been entertaining French-speaking audiences there in intimate little venues.

The distance between those rooms and the American summit measured her journey.

Radio stations from coast to coast reported the same delighted listener response.

By February she was being booked onto America’s biggest television programmes.

The Christmas season, meant to bury new records, had launched hers instead.

Photo: Pye / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain
Photo: Pye / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

One Song, Four Languages

Clark quickly recorded the song in French, German and Italian for Europe.

No other language offered a tidy two-syllable word meaning quite the same thing.

Each version therefore needed its story rebuilt almost from the beginning again.

The French version, “Dans le temps,” carried the melody to French listeners.

The Italian version, “Ciao Ciao,” won the Festivalbar jukebox contest in Italy.

The German version kept the title “Downtown” and reached number one there.

A Spanish version, sung by other artists, topped the charts in Spain.

Few British singles had ever spoken so fluently to so many countries.

Each foreign version turned one New York walk into a local romance.

Clark’s French career, once a refuge, became the engine of the feat.

The Song That Would Not Leave

The American industry voted “Downtown” its Grammy for Best Rock and Roll Recording.

Hatch eventually received the 1981 Ivor Novello award for the song’s craftsmanship.

Frank Sinatra recorded his own elegant version for a 1966 album of standards.

Dolly Parton and Emma Bunton later carried it to new generations of listeners.

In 1988 a remixed “Downtown ’88” returned Clark to the British top ten.

In 2013 she re-recorded it as a gentle ballad for her album Lost in You.

Filmmakers kept borrowing it, from Girl, Interrupted to Last Night in Soho.

Its recording now sits enshrined in the Grammy Hall of Fame permanently.

It remains the recording her name summons first in almost every country.

The song’s three minutes have never really left the world’s jukebox since.

Perhaps you know the feeling of a week that has worn you thin.

Maybe you, too, keep one bright street where your spirits always recover.

Her brightest lights always burned in another city.

The whole world learned her directions home.

Petula Clark: The First Lady of the British Invasion

Sally of Ewell

She was born Sally Clark on November 15, 1932, in Ewell, Surrey.

Her parents, Doris and Leslie Clark, both worked as nurses in Epsom.

Her mother brought Welsh roots to the household, her father English ones.

It was her father who invented “Petula” as her stage name early on.

Part of her childhood unfolded in Abercanaid, a Welsh village near Merthyr Tydfil.

Her grandfather there worked underground as a coal miner in the pits.

She sang in the chapel choir and entertained family with uncanny mimicry.

Little Sally impersonated Vera Lynn, Carmen Miranda and Sophie Tucker for relatives.

Nobody yet knew the mimic would become one of Britain’s defining voices.

She first sang for a live audience in 1939, aged six.

The Night the Sirens Interrupted

In the autumn of 1942 she attended a BBC broadcast with her father.

The nine-year-old hoped to record a message for an uncle serving overseas.

An air raid delayed the programme and unsettled the theatre audience badly.

The producer asked whether somebody would sing to calm the jittery crowd.

Clark volunteered and sang “Mighty Lak’ a Rose” to an enthusiastic response.

The BBC repeated her performance for the broadcast audience listening at home.

That evening launched roughly five hundred appearances entertaining troops during wartime.

She became known as the “Singing Sweetheart” to servicemen across the country.

Audiences also nicknamed her “Britain’s Shirley Temple” for her sunny professionalism.

She performed for King George the Sixth, Winston Churchill and Field Marshal Montgomery.

Some soldiers pasted her photograph onto their tanks as a good-luck mascot.

She toured Britain alongside another young performer named Julie Andrews.

Photo: Unknown author / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain
Photo: Unknown author / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

From Radio to the Film Studios

While singing at the Royal Albert Hall in 1944, a film director noticed.

Maurice Elvey cast the twelve-year-old as an orphan in Medal for the General.

More films followed quickly, including the celebrated I Know Where I’m Going!

She played a Huggett daughter in three popular Huggett family comedies.

She acted opposite Anthony Newley in Vice Versa and Alec Guinness in The Card.

Television arrived early for her too, with BBC variety appearances in 1946.

Soon she was hosting her own afternoon series for the BBC cameras.

By her mid-teens she had worked in radio, film, television and print.

Yet music, the thing that started everything, kept quietly calling her back.

All the while, radio and records kept pulling her back toward music.

A Label Built Around a Daughter

In 1949 she recorded her first releases, beginning her life on record.

That year producer Alan A. Freeman joined forces with her father Leslie.

Together the two men formed Polygon Records largely to present her talent.

The little label was financed partly from the young singer’s own earnings.

Her father had promoted her career from its very first wartime broadcast.

Now his belief in her was literally built into a record company.

Under Polygon she learned the studio craft that later defined her sound.

Freeman had been introduced to her by pianist Joe Henderson in 1949.

The family’s investment in the daughter would pay off for decades afterwards.

The Fifties Songbook

Her first big British hit arrived in 1954 with “The Little Shoemaker.”

That record also reached number one in Australia, her first overseas triumph.

“Majorca” and “Suddenly There’s a Valley” kept her on the British charts.

“With All My Heart” became one of her signature ballads of the decade.

Late in 1955, Polygon was sold into the Pye group of labels.

The sale effectively signed her to Pye, her home for many years.

Through the fifties she was a dependable British star, polished and familiar.

Familiarity, though, can quietly become a ceiling for an ambitious young singer.

Her next great chapter would not be written in Britain at all.

Her records also sold respectably abroad, finding early friends in Australia.

Still, Britain had begun filing her under yesterday’s news by decade’s end.

Paris Changes Everything

In 1957 she was invited to perform at the famous Paris Olympia.

Despite her misgivings and a heavy cold, the Paris audience acclaimed her.

The next day she visited the offices of the French label Vogue.

There she met Claude Wolff, the publicist assigned to work with her.

She later said she agreed to sign partly because he came with it.

A major French-language career followed, with records made for French audiences.

She toured France and Belgium and recorded in German, Italian and Spanish.

In June 1961 she married Wolff, and France became her home base.

Her French hit “Chariot” later became famous in English as “I Will Follow Him.”

At Vogue she recorded the French repertoire that made her truly adored.

Within a few years, French audiences treated her as one of their own.

Photo: Unknown author / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0
Photo: Unknown author / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

Sailor Brings Her Home

Even while building France, she kept one foot in the British charts.

In 1961 her recording of “Sailor” became her first British number one.

Young Tony Hatch had assisted producer Alan A. Freeman on those sessions.

“Romeo” followed her into the British top ten and sold a million copies.

That success earned her the first gold disc of her long career.

“My Friend the Sea” kept her British momentum alive a little longer.

Then the hits thinned, and by 1964 Britain had largely looked away.

It took a song about New York to bring the whole world back.

Her British chart life and her French career now ran in parallel.

Photo: Henk Lindeboom, Anefo / Wikimedia Commons, CC0
Photo: Henk Lindeboom, Anefo / Wikimedia Commons, CC0

The American Years

“Downtown” began a run of fifteen consecutive American top forty hits.

“I Know a Place” reached number three and won her another Grammy award.

Her vocal performance on it took the contemporary vocal prize for 1965.

“My Love,” another Hatch song, gave her a second American number one.

“A Sign of the Times” and “I Couldn’t Live Without Your Love” followed strongly.

Charlie Chaplin wrote “This Is My Song” for her, a British number one.

That record also climbed to number three on the American charts in 1967.

“Don’t Sleep in the Subway” completed her great run that same year.

Between 1965 and 1968, nine of her singles reached America’s top twenty.

America crowned her “the First Lady of the British Invasion” during those years.

Two MIDEM awards honoured her unmatched worldwide sales as a female artist.

Television followed the records, with Sullivan and Martin welcoming her repeatedly.

She toured American theatres and nightclubs between recording sessions in London.

Photo: ABC Television / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain
Photo: ABC Television / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

One Small Gesture on Television

In 1968 NBC invited her to host her own American television special.

Her guest was Harry Belafonte, and together they sang her song “On the Path of Glory.”

During the duet, she simply took hold of Belafonte’s arm as they sang.

A representative of sponsor Chrysler objected to the moment and demanded another take.

He feared the gentle gesture would provoke a backlash among Southern viewers.

Clark and her husband Wolff, the programme’s executive producer, refused outright.

They destroyed the other takes so only the touching version could survive.

The special aired on April 8, 1968, to strong ratings and warm reviews.

The programme earned an Emmy nomination and permanent television history status.

Photo: Plymouth / Chrysler / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain
Photo: Plymouth / Chrysler / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

The Stage Becomes a Second Home

Her 1968 film Finian’s Rainbow earned her a Golden Globe acting nomination.

Years later she played Maria in a London revival of The Sound of Music.

In 1993 she made her Broadway debut in the musical Blood Brothers.

Appearing opposite David Cassidy, she helped rescue that struggling production completely.

She later toured triumphantly as Norma Desmond in Sunset Boulevard across two countries.

In 2019, at eighty-six, she joined Mary Poppins in London’s West End.

There she played the Bird Woman for delighted audiences night after night.

Each new stage seemed to reopen a career that refused to close.

She had shared the screen with Fred Astaire in that earlier film.

Her stage work won a respect that pop fame alone rarely grants.

Honors and the Long Encore

Estimates credit her with around one hundred million records sold worldwide.

In 1998 she was appointed a Commander of the Order of the British Empire.

France, her adopted home, honoured her repeatedly across her long career there.

Her husband of sixty-three years, Claude Wolff, died in 2024.

She mourned privately, as she had lived much of her life offstage.

Even in her nineties she continued to record and perform for audiences.

Her 2013 album Lost in You returned her voice to record shops worldwide.

Eight decades on, she is still arriving.

Photo: Georges Biard / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0
Photo: Georges Biard / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

The Second Take

So return to Studio One on that October Friday in 1964.

The orchestra is still waiting, and Hatch is still behind the washroom door.

The singer at the microphone has been famous, forgotten and famous abroad.

What she does not know is that America is about to claim her.

The second take will carry a Paris-based Englishwoman to the American summit.

Within three months she will hold the first number one of 1965.

Children who heard her during the war will hear grandchildren sing her.

Her brightest lights always burned in another city.

And somewhere tonight, the neon is still switching on just for her.

Leave a Comment

120visits all-time 12today